Beyond True or False: Measuring Information Discernment in a Simulated Joint Operations Environment

Open Access
Article
Conference Proceedings
Authors: Melissa Mclain, Sarah Bostrom, Richard Niemeyer, Leanne Hirshfield
Abstract

Information disorder and adversarial exploitation of human cognition pose growing challenges for military decision making in saturated information environments. Although most research focused on veracity discernment, operational settings require broader information discernment: evaluating, contextualizing, and determining whether information should influence decisions and action. This study addressed limitation of laboratory paradigms and classified operation settings through an iterative experiment in the U.S. Air Force Academy’s Multi-Domain Laboratory (MDL), an unclassified simulation of a joint all-domain operations center. Across two semesters, measures were refined for assessing information interaction in a naturalistic, high-information density (HID) environment. Initial instruments emphasized decision and response selection but could not distinguish participants who failed to notice information from those who identified it as inaccurate or irrelevant. Fall 2025 methods incorporated component-specific, time-stamped information supplements and retrospective debrief measures of information belief and decision influence. Findings and results from 771 observations are presented to explore the debrief instrument’s utility for assessing metacognitive processes underlying information discernment without disrupting wargame execution.

Keywords: Naturalistic Decision Making, Human-Systems Integration, Information Processing Model, Information Discernment, Information Disorder

DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1008349

Cite this paper
Downloads
0
Visits
1
Download PDF

More from this volume

← Impact of Body Mass Index, Tenure Length, and Age on Physical Exertion of Transportation Maintenance Workers during Simulated Asphalt ShovelingA Multidimensional Framework for Assessing Human-AI Collaboration in Military Operations: The CogARMY Teamwork Index (CTI) →
View all articles in Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing →