Assessing Organisational Capability for Meaningful Human Oversight of AI-Supported Work: A Human Factors Framework

Open Access
Article
Conference Proceedings
Authors: Ayoola Rilwan Lawal, Romans Putans
Abstract

Human oversight is adopted as a control measure for workplace artificial intelligence; assigning responsibility does not establish whether workers can identify errors, question recommendations, or intervene effectively. This paper proposes a human factors framework for assessing conditions that enable meaningful oversight within a defined AI-supported task. The framework was established using a purposive conceptual synthesis of human factors research, organisational studies, EU AI Act provisions, and AI assessment guidance. It builds on questions raised by the authors’ published study (Lawal, Koppel, and Putans, 2026), which provided background motivation. Its findings are not presented as new evidence or validation of this proposal. The assessment covers four areas: understanding, intervention authority, working conditions, and organisational support. Each specifies assessment questions, evidence of effective implementation, and organisational responses to gaps. The procedure defines the task, identifies personnel responsible for performance and supervision, and specifies plausible erroneous AI recommendations. It assesses whether overseers have sufficient information and time to evaluate outputs and consequences and respond appropriately. Evidence may include organisational records, direct observation of human-AI work, and realistic failure exercises assessing recognition, challenge, and response. Findings distinguish absent evidence from demonstrated deficiency within each domain. A hypothetical maintenance allocation example illustrates organisational barriers to intervention. The framework translates oversight expectations into workplace assessment criteria and organisational responses. It remains empirically unvalidated. Operational evaluation should compare it with existing approaches and examine content coverage, usability, inter-assessor reliability, and its relationship to personnel’s intervention capacity. The proposal does not establish legal compliance or demonstrate improved safety.

Keywords: Human Factors, Human Oversight, Workplace AI, Organisational Capability, Organisational Governance

DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1008363

Cite this paper
Downloads
0
Visits
1
Download PDF

More from this volume

← A Human–AI Collaborative Mechanism for Commercial Packaging Design with Generative AIEmerging Technologies and AI in Aviation: Reshaping the Roles and Responsibilities of Human Factors →
View all articles in Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing →