Metacognitive Scaffolding for Novice Designers in Generative AI-Assisted Poster Design: A Formative Study of Premature Convergence

Open Access
Article
Conference Proceedings
Authors: Shuai Sun, Yu Yangwenqing
Abstract

Generative artificial intelligence makes poster creation accessible to novice designers, but polished initial outputs may encourage premature convergence. This study develops an early poster-design prototype that embeds planning, monitoring, and evaluation scaffolds within a structured workflow and examines its use formatively. Thirteen participants without systematic design training completed a fixed A-to-B within-participant comparison: freely combining AI tools in condition A, followed by using the prototype in condition B. Human coding of recordings informed fixation-related process measures; intent-alignment ratings, an experience questionnaire, and interview summaries provided complementary evidence. Mean fixation-duration proportion was 34.9% in A and 18.3% in B, a difference of -16.6 percentage points (bootstrap 95% CI [-24.9, -8.1]; exact p = .005). Conceptual-frame counts increased by 1.154 on average and retained a statistical signal after Holm adjustment. Fixation-event rate did not differ significantly, and intent alignment did not retain a statistical signal after adjustment. All four experience dimensions were rated more positively in B. These observations identify broader exploration and a lower proportion of effective creation time coded as fixation-related within this sample. The small sample, fixed order, unequal creation times, bundled components, and measurement limitations restrict generalization and causal interpretation. The contribution is a concrete metacognitive scaffolding design and formative evidence that identifies priorities for controlled evaluation.

Keywords: Generative Artificial Intelligence, Design Fixation, Metacognitive Regulation, Poster Design, Human-AI Collaboration

DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1008390

Cite this paper
Downloads
0
Visits
1
Download PDF

More from this volume

← Sharing the Edge: Multiple Concurrent Neural Workloads on a Single Microcontroller in a Smart HVAC VentHuman-Object Interaction Spatial Constraint-Driven Intelligent Generative Design for Products →
View all articles in Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing →