The Disclosure Paradox: A Human Factor Framework to Medical Error Disclosure

Open Access
Article
Conference Proceedings
Authors: Zoher Rafid-Hamed, Jay Kalra
Abstract

Disclosure of adverse events is essential to managing the consequences of medical error, yet the period immediately following an error may be when healthcare providers feel least prepared to communicate openly. Fear of blame, litigation, reputational harm, and damage to the physician-patient relationship may discourage disclosure. However, failure to disclose can compromise patient autonomy and trust while increasing provider isolation and distress. We propose a quadrant model in which two independent factors shape responses to medical error: transparency of disclosure and support for patients, families, and healthcare providers. Their interaction produces four states: Silence, when both transparency and support are lacking; Insulation, when providers receive support without appropriate disclosure; Exposure, when disclosure occurs without adequate support; and Restoration, when honest disclosure is accompanied by meaningful support. To promote Restoration and reduce recurrence, we introduce the seven-domain “RESTORE” Framework: Recognition of the adverse event and its impact; Ethical, patient-centred disclosure; Support for patients, families, and providers; Transparency about known and uncertain information; Opportunity to restore trust and professional integrity; Reflection on individual and systemic contributing factors; and Evaluation and improvement. A restorative approach keeps patients and families central while recognizing that disclosure without support and support without disclosure are incomplete responses. Integrating transparency, support, reflection, and quality improvement can move healthcare beyond blame and isolation toward healing, learning, and safer, higher-quality patient care.

Keywords: Medical Error, Disclosure, Patient Safety, Quality Care, Human Factor

DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1008443

Cite this paper
Downloads
0
Visits
1
Download PDF

More from this volume

← Health Psychology in the Digital Age: Cyberchondria, Health Anxiety, and Online Health Information-Seeking BehaviorsAnalysis of Mechanical Loads on the Handrail During Stair Ascent at the Initiation and Completion Phases →
View all articles in Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing →