Measuring What Generative AI Actually Saves in Instructor-Led Training Development: A Matched-Deliverable Time-and-Quality Comparison

Open Access
Article
Conference Proceedings
Authors: Richard Stone, Anthony Lavazza, Michael Jenkins, Claire Carter, Lixsa Barraza, Meagan Ault
Abstract

Instructor-led training (ILT) is a core delivery mode for workforce development, safety, equipment familiarization, and procedural instruction, and producing it is expensive. Generative Artificial Intelligence (AI) promises to cut that cost, and organizations want a number they can trust. The obstacle is measurement. The metrics that are easiest to capture, software-recorded editing time and time per slide, are unreliable, and the apparent advantage of AI can appear or vanish depending on what is counted. ILT slides are deliberately sparse because the instructor carries the content, so word count per slide says little about completeness, and recorded editing time counts only work done inside the slide file. This paper fixes the deliverable instead: a complete teachable module of defined instructional scope, including slides, instructor talking points, activities, and assessment items, sufficient for a qualified instructor to deliver. Development time is measured to that standard and normalized per learning objective and per minute of instruction. Three workflows produced the same module from the same source material: an experienced designer, a junior designer, and a designer working with generative AI followed by Subject Matter Expert (SME) review. The AI-assisted workflow reached a complete module in 5 person-hours against 32 and 56, but drafting fell 94 percent while review and revision rose to 65 percent of what remained. The contribution is a matched-deliverable method that lets organizations state AI productivity gains defensibly rather than rhetorically, with guidance for safe adoption in safety-critical domains.

Keywords: Generative AI, Instructor-Led Training, Instructional Design, Productivity Measurement, Safety Training, Human-AI Teaming

DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1008495

Cite this paper
Downloads
0
Visits
1
Download PDF

More from this volume

← System Awareness, Context Awareness, and Situational Trust in Human-AI Decision Making for Military Command and ControlFULL PAPER ONLY: Beyond Tools: A Task-Based Human-AI Studio Scaffold for Critical Thinking in Architectural Education →
View all articles in Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing →