The Vigilance Decrement in the Wild: How to Study and Design for Long-Term Process Monitoring

Open Access
Article
Conference Proceedings
Authors: Kelly Dickerson, Courtney Thomas, Ronald Boring
Abstract

Several industries have made shifts towards highly automated or autonomous operations, with driving, aviation, and maritime operations serving as the most common examples. These concepts of operations shift the human from active operator to supervisory controller. Supervisory control requires consistent system monitoring to ensure success if human intervention becomes necessary. New build commercial nuclear power plants are being developed to leverage significant automation and autonomy, using sophisticated distributed control systems to manage and control the plant while human monitors continuously observe ongoing processes and trends. Process monitoring requires vigilance, the ability to remain alert and attentive while observing to detect a low likelihood event (e.g., abnormal plant conditions). Vigilance decrement is the degradation on monitoring performance over time and has been a known human performance issue since 1948 (Mackworth, 1948) with over 3,000 publications specifically on vigilance decrement. Despite the size of the literature, this research has translated into limited practical interface and job design guidance. This paper reviews and summarizes the primary theoretical frameworks posited as explanations and outlines a simulator-based method for studying and characterizing vigilance in a scientifically rigorous way that can be directly translated into actionable design insights. The study methodology proposes a multidimensional measurement approach, using physiological, survey-, and performance-based measures to capture the magnitude and timeline of the vigilance decrement over the course of a 2-hour observation interval.

Keywords: Vigilance, Human Systems Integration, Nuclear Process Control, Attention, Automation

DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1008502

Cite this paper
Downloads
0
Visits
2
Download PDF

More from this volume

← Detection Without Speed Isn’t Defense: Human-AI Coordination Against Cognitive CyberattackersOpenIN X: A Dual-Path Wearable Auditory Interface for Divided-Attention Support in Unilateral Conductive Hearing Loss →
View all articles in Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing →