E Contextibus Unum: When Should Your AI Share Your Information with Others?

Open Access
Article
Conference Proceedings
Authors: Enya Bullard, Xiang Chen
Abstract

As large language models (LLMs) become increasingly integrated into collaborative environments, questions arise about how user contexts such as prompts, conversation histories, and preferences might be shared across users to enhance collective intelligence and personalization. Although technical implementations of context sharing have been explored, it remains unclear how to design interfaces that appropriately engage users with context sharing. This study investigates how users perceive the trade-offs between usefulness, privacy, and control when their contexts are shared with other users through LLM-mediated interactions. Through a Wizard-of-Oz study with scenario-based probes, we examine both the sharer’s perspective (those whose context is being used) and the receiver’s perspective (those benefiting from others’ contexts). Our work aims to surface guidelines for designing LLM interfaces for transparent, user-centered context sharing systems that balance collective benefit with individual privacy and autonomy. This provides engineers with opportunities to design LLM assistants that leverage aggregated user data to provide useful insights. Our key findings reveal that: (1) context sharing acceptability varies by domain: professional contexts showed high acceptance while health contexts demanded expert authority over community insights, and mental health contexts produced polarized responses based on personal disclosure comfort; (2) most participants preferred statistical aggregations over individual anecdotes, demonstrating an LLM-specific trust mechanism where data-driven validation matters more than personal stories; and (3) control is essential for acceptance, but must avoid decision fatigue through domain-based preferences and keyword rules rather than requiring per-interaction consent decisions.

Keywords: Large Language Models, Context Sharing, Privacy, User Control, Human-AI Interaction, Wizard-of-Oz Study

DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1008262

Cite this paper
Downloads
0
Visits
1
Download PDF

More from this volume

← Focus Pup: A Design Study on a Companion Robot for Self-Management Among Adults with ADHDA Lifelog System for Automatically Linking Physical Operations and Measurement Data in Hardware Debugging →
View all articles in Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing →