Rethinking Inclusivity in Dissonant Heritage

Open Access
Article
Conference Proceedings
Authors: Valeria Minucciani, Gabriella Dalla Serra
Abstract

Nowadays, approaches to cultural heritage increasingly promote objectives of inclusivity, participation and accessibility. Yet can heritage interpretation and enhancement processes truly be considered inclusive if certain memories and narratives remain marginalised or excluded?The paper follows a progressive line of inquiry, moving from questioning inclusivity as applied to heritage, to analysing how this concept may be redefined when dealing with dissonant heritage and finally examining selected case studies illustrating how such a reframed understanding may become operational.Cultural dissonance originates from the selective nature of heritagisation, through which certain cultural expressions are assigned the status of heritage. It arises when heritagisation encounters dramatic memories, contested values and conflicting narratives, which challenge traditional practice with heritage.Thus a paradox emerges: while the “Design For All” is generally geared towards conflict resolution, in dissonant heritage contexts inclusivity may instead be achieved by making conflict visible. Interpretative tensions should therefore not be removed but revealed to foster constructive dialogue.Yet making conflict visible also means acknowledging the existence of silenced memories and marginalised narratives, thus challenging the assumption that heritage interpretation and enhancement are inherently inclusive processes. On the contrary, they reflect social and political power structures, therefore making inclusivity both a technical and political issue.In conclusion, the paper argues that inclusivity in dissonant heritage should not be understood as the resolution of interpretative conflict, but rather as its recognition. It should depend less on achieving consensus than on critically engaging with disagreement: revealing rather than hiding, provoking rather than appeasing.

Keywords: Dissonance, Heritagisation, Conflict, Memory

DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1008292

Cite this paper
Downloads
0
Visits
1
Download PDF

More from this volume

← Towards Participatory Requirements Gathering of Constantly Evolving User Needs for Smart Cane+Trend Analysis of Cognitive Ability in Three Long‑Duration Working Groups Based on Piecewise Linear Regression →
View all articles in Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing →