Human-Centred Adaptive Reuse of Building Heritage: A Comparative Ex-Post and Ex-Ante Evaluation of abandoned areas in Maribor, Slovenia

Open Access
Article
Conference Proceedings
Authors: Vesna Zegarac Leskovar, Vanja Skalicky Klemenčič
Abstract

Adaptive reuse has become an important strategy for preserving building heritage while addressing contemporary environmental, social, and cultural challenges. Yet the social dimension of adaptive reuse and users' experiences remain insufficiently explored in evaluation practice. Furthermore, existing evaluation methods are primarily applied to completed projects and rarely support the assessment of projects still under development.This paper develops a Human-Centred Adaptive Reuse Evaluation Framework (HCAREF) for building heritage, investigating whether human-centred design principles can be applied to both retrospective (ex-post) and prospective (ex-ante) evaluations. A literature review on adaptive reuse and human-centred design was conducted to identify the key evaluation dimensions, forming an integrated framework that was then applied to three case studies from Maribor, Slovenia. Two completed projects, the Minorite Monastery Complex and the Judgement Tower, were evaluated ex post through field observations and document analysis, while the Centre Rotovž project was assessed ex ante using project documentation, architectural drawings, and visualisations.The findings indicate that the proposed framework can support the evaluation of adaptive reuse projects at different stages of development, providing a practical decision-support tool for architects, planners, and heritage professionals while advancing the integration of human-centred principles into adaptive reuse practice. The framework provides a structured basis for comparing realised qualities in completed projects with intended qualities in an ongoing project.

Keywords: Human-Centred Design, Adaptive Reuse, Building Heritage, Evaluation Framework, Ex-Post Evaluation, Ex-Ante Evaluation

DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1008297

Cite this paper
Downloads
0
Visits
1
Download PDF

More from this volume

← Governing Agentic AI Workflows: Balancing Automation and Human Oversight in Enterprise PracticeDEM Cropper: A Web-Based Geospatial Processing System for Physical Terrain Representation →
View all articles in Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing →