Integrating human factors with safety risk management through the Bowtie Analysis: Forming a commercial pilot mental health risk management system

Open Access
Article
Conference Proceedings
Authors: Mark Miller, Sam Holley, Aric Raus
Abstract

Commercial pilot mental health has become a complicated issue in the United States. While a portion of the pilot population would like to seek help openly with their ongoing mental health problems, many of those pilots are unwilling to seek the help due to the risk it poses in jeopardizing their pilot careers. While pilots with current mental health issues are unwilling to visibly gain the help they need, many other pilots are potentially borderline dealing with oncoming mental issues due to being under tremendous pressure with fatigue and stress issues underlying their performance. The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) has recently addressed the issue, but the FAA, the airlines, the pilots’ union and the pilots are still hard pressed to come up with a working solution. The researchers propose that such a complex aviation safety issue infused with human factors (HF) should be analyzed from a different perspective of risk management (RM) and HF through a safety technique called the Bowtie method that is designed to both deal with prevention and reducing the consequences through RM. By integrating realistic prevention programs, the researchers complete a risk assessment (RA) of the preventative left side of the Bowtie. The researchers then integrate realistic recovery mitigations to reduce the consequences followed by the RA of the right side of the Bowtie. In both cases of RA on the prevention and recovery sides of the Bowtie analysis, both RA matrix and mathematical probability support the risk reduction. The safety RM analysis of the HF interventions through the Bowtie method proves that the complex problem of pilot mental health may not ever be 100 % resolved but instead can be adequately managed by RM HF interventions through the Bowtie method integrated into a pilot mental health RM Safety Management System (SMS).

Keywords: Bowtie, Risk Management, Human Factors, Risk Assessment, SMS

DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1008411

Cite this paper
Downloads
0
Visits
1
Download PDF

More from this volume

← Architecting an Integrated Data Management and Governance Ecosystem for Enhancing Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs) Promotion in ThailandTrust Calibration and Surveillance Auditing in Human-AI Co-Ideation →
View all articles in Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing →