Trust Calibration and Surveillance Auditing in Human-AI Co-Ideation

Open Access
Article
Conference Proceedings
Authors: Akram Bayat
Abstract

As generative artificial intelligence becomes deeply embedded in computing and design education, instructors face the urgent challenge of teaching students to think critically about machine suggestions rather than trusting them uncritically. This paper evaluates a structured, classroom-ready Human-AI Co-Ideation Workshop designed to protect student creative agency and reduce automation bias. In the activity, students tackled a forward-looking design challenge focused on student wellbeing and academic success. We introduced a deliberate pedagogical delay by dividing the workshop into sequential stages: students first generated initial design ideas entirely on paper without computers, then used multiple commercial language models to expand their concepts, and finally completed a comparative gap analysis and reflection. Analyzing student design worksheets, conversational interaction logs, and reflective essays revealed four consistent patterns: students struggled to bridge personal lived experiences with broad institutional systems; articulate machine outputs created a "Smoothness Trap" that discouraged questioning; learners had to actively protect their design confidence against polished machine text; and students practiced "defensive curation" by identifying and stripping out invasive surveillance and behavioral tracking mechanisms introduced by automated models. This paper provides instructors with an adaptable workshop structure, an evaluation rubric, and practical teaching strategies to help students collaborate with AI safely and thoughtfully.

Keywords: Human-AI Co-Ideation, Trust Calibration, Surveillance Auditing, Automation Bias, Design Education, Critical AI Literacy

DOI: 10.54941/ahfe1008412

Cite this paper
Downloads
0
Visits
1
Download PDF

More from this volume

← Integrating human factors with safety risk management through the Bowtie Analysis: Forming a commercial pilot mental health risk management systemHow and Why Did the Lack of LCES Contribute to Fatal Outcomes in the June 1990 Dude Fire, July 1994 South Canyon, and June 2013 Yarnell Hill Fire? →
View all articles in Human Factors in Design, Engineering, and Computing →